Judge Finds Widow Lacks Merit to Sue

Sunday, July 12th, 2009

A Manhattan judge ruled that a widow’s claim for a $9 million malpractice suit for her husband’s attorneys have no merit.  Marilyn Shafer, Supreme Court Justice, ruled that there was no privity between Jean Sorenson Leff, the widow, and Richard Cunningham and William Bush, the attorneys.

Shafer discounted the argument of Leff that occasional interactions between her and the attorneys, which includes her own will preparation, created an attorney-client relationship with regards to her husband’s estate planning.  Shafer wrote that “even if the plaintiff has a subjective belief of an attorney-client relationship, it’s not enough evidence that there is one.”

Due to this, a question was raised on who can sue for malpractice in New York when the attorneys make mistakes in estate planning.  The chair of wills and estates department for Schlesinger Gannon & Lazetera answered, “New York is one of the very few states left with privity doctrine.  Only the decedent has the privity and the right to sue - not even the executor or administrator of the estate could charge malpractice to the attorneys.  Fortunately, more and more states are moving to abandon that doctrine.”

Tags: attorney-client relationship, attorneys, Jean Sorenson Leff, malpractice, Manhattan, Marilyn Shafer, New York, privity, Richard Cunningham, Supreme Court Justice, William Bush
Posted in Estate Planning, Wills | No Comments »